The Scandal of Christendom

Following the death of Peter, Prince James was crowned king of Sicily in Palermo in February 1286. The eldest son, Alfonso, was tentatively king of Aragon, but his title as Alfonso III Honorius IV would not be confirmed until April. However, Alfonso did not wait to be confirmed but instead moved against King James of Mallorca, swiftly conquering Mallorca and Ibiza, and later Minorca, so that by 1286 the Balearic Islands were under direct control of Aragon. In France, Philip IV had come to the throne at the age of seventeen, and while relatively young, he would prove to be a shrewd ruler. Charles of Salerno was still a prisoner of the Aragonese, so the Count of Artois was to act as regent of the Regno until his eventual release. In Rome, the anti-French faction in the papacy had obtained enough influence to block the election of another French pope and force a compromise with the election of a member of the local Savelli family, Edward I Honorius IV. Each of the parties had enough internal problems that there was a very real incentive to end the war. However, reaching an agreement that satisfied all of the parties would prove extremely difficult.

The year 1286 had started with an embassy to Rome sent by King James of Sicily offering homage to the pope in return for recognition of his title. However, in many ways Honorius IV had not gained any insights to the current problems from watching the defeats of his predecessors. He was still unwilling to acknowledge the independence of Sicily and responded by excommunicating James, Queen Constance, and the entire population of Sicily. Moreover, in an attempt to win back the populations of Calabria and Apulia which had gone over to the Aragonese side, he made the same promises Martin IV and Charles of Anjou had to reform the Angevin government, promises which were received with the same level of skepticism as the earlier proposals. Edward I of England, whose papal ambassador Odo of Grandisonhad called the war "the scandal of Christendom", attempted to mediate between France and Aragon, but the papal refusal to separate Sicily from the Regno stalled any comprehensive settlement, and the talks dragged on into 1287.